forked from Manuel/meeting-assistant
30 lines
4.7 KiB
Markdown
30 lines
4.7 KiB
Markdown
# SOLID review receipt — Ticket 01
|
|
|
|
Reviewer: independent `/root/review_solid`; read-only review on 2026-10-03. No candidate edits, application starts, live-service actions or repeated test runs.
|
|
|
|
Repository: `/private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-closeout`. Fixed base: `1b19b08f2e62398661dc24692ce4b776e90e715f` (`fork/codex/macos-support`, resolved from refs and confirmed by coordinator).
|
|
|
|
Candidate identity:
|
|
|
|
- Diff: `/private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-review-final.diff`, SHA-256 `40c69e017e5047b0d59348d22ec879122a9f6d02f4f232843847e8fdefe98dac`.
|
|
- Scoped current-content manifest: `/private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-reviewed-content.sha256`, SHA-256 `b411b6ddffc6ca4e7c2a76c37ff48a49253073e0382abd0ccb213bc531be2a82` (51 code, spec, config and documentation files). All 51 current file checksums match. Generated evidence/hash records are outside this identity.
|
|
- Scope: existing macOS communication prerequisite plus Ticket 01 test-target, isolation, verifier and CI changes; future parity-owner implementations excluded.
|
|
|
|
Result: **clean; no actionable binding-rule violation or material SOLID heuristic finding**.
|
|
|
|
Coverage: inspected the diff and surrounding production/test code against repository AGENTS.md, README, relevant OpenSpec requirements/design/tasks, and the current Windows assurance evidence. Checked coherent request-lifecycle ownership, existing prompt interface substitution, validation and failure contracts, original callback lifetimes, shutdown/duplicate/expired response behavior, native transport versus managed business ownership, independent session lifetime and prompt startup, lazy dependency resolution, matching application/test TFMs, Windows/native helper isolation, fixture-only hosted-service suppression with explicit re-enablement, and CI/verifier fail-closed evidence contracts. C#/.NET preference is satisfied by the standalone verifier; Swift is confined to the existing Apple-framework helper boundary. Source/CI ownership stays in this repository; no deployment or active-meeting action is introduced by closeout.
|
|
|
|
Requirements evidence reviewed and reused: 641 portable results (639 passed, 2 reasoned Windows skips); 22 Linux focused cases (15 passed, 7 reasoned skips); 21 HTTP checks; 38 synthetic verifier fixture cases; seven actual native helper groups. Current normal Windows application and test builds pass with zero errors and no resource suppression after the existing core tray-package correction. Coordinator confirmed the refreshed portable suite used the unchanged candidate inputs.
|
|
|
|
Unverified boundaries remain explicit: real Windows-TFM discovery/assertion execution, CI runner execution/artifact publication, native notification/menu UI acceptance and later parity-ticket operations. An exit-zero discovery with testhost error and no cases is rejected, not counted as evidence. OpenSpec Task 1.1 and original communication Tasks 4.2/4.4 remain unchecked. This receipt grants no commit, push, merge, archive or ticket-close authority.
|
|
|
|
## Bounded refresh after KISS-01
|
|
|
|
Current identity: `/private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-reviewed-content-v2.sha256`, SHA-256 `147f83cfe076e27aa5ff29eedc8e9084e2b2e9ee39f9c7ab8a5d834100a0928d` (52 files); `/private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-review-final-v2.diff`, SHA-256 `6a9e70bb5dcf0e20f19dd029bdd251f14e528d03037a0a35140254b03066a28b`. Both identity hashes and all 52 current file checksums matched. Original 51-file coverage above remains valid without reopening unchanged implementation.
|
|
|
|
Only additional binding delta reviewed: five lines in `openspec/changes/add-macos-desktop-controls/specs/meeting-session/spec.md` correct the existing owner's automatic-approval scenario. Unanswered pending workflow/project requests expire or cancel without mutating an agent conversation; notification hiding/dismissal cannot approve them. Spec SHA-256: `7dde9acdcbf2b0917e91e82d1078cb1405d715379eb98f68ea5eff09c48697de`.
|
|
|
|
Result: **clean; no new SOLID finding**. The corrected owner scenario is coherent with the managed request lifetime, explicit-Yes adapter contract, workflow owner's guarded window creation, public project-association refusal path, and native delegate's ignored dismiss/default actions. It places the fallback rule with its existing desktop owner and introduces no dependency, responsibility or substitution conflict. Unrelated future parity requirements remain excluded.
|
|
|
|
Reused actual requirements evidence from `artifacts/tests/ticket01/closeout/receipt.md` and its `contract-delta-proof.txt`: current TRX Passed records for deadline/origin cancellation, both approval expiry/cancellation cases, workflow denied/expired/shutdown, and all four unapproved/stale project-association cases; corrected owner strict validation passed. No test repetition or source edits were performed. Prior Windows runtime/CI and real native UI acceptance limitations are unchanged.
|