10 KiB
Ticket 02 — accepted preparation closeout
Date: 2026-10-06. Local Ticket 02 is closed on the user's explicit acceptance of its prepared scope. That scope is technically complete; final document/identity checks are recorded in closeout/final-checks.md. Full original Windows acceptance remains verification-incomplete. A local implementation commit is authorized, but its necessary pre-existing prerequisite inclusion remains a separate unresolved scope decision. No commit or push is claimed here. This change is not archived.
Scope and identity
Git root: meeting-assistant; requested delivery branch: codex/macos-support; unchanged current HEAD: 1164c26846686c1912fd1816cd06de80352e9504. The review base is this SHA plus the exact recorded pre-Ticket02 dirty baseline, not a claim that HEAD already contains the prerequisites.
The accepted slice adds three tests through the registered Windows crop interface, fail-closed named discovery/TRX rules and their synthetic checker tests, known German/English synthetic two-voice WAVs with reference manifests and a .NET file-based generator, and the documented Windows acceptance procedure. Production crop behavior, backend selection and application semantics are unchanged.
The exact 15-path reviewed write set, four previous implementation/document files, fixed current snapshot and binary diff are retained under ignored artifacts/tests/ticket02/closeout/. Four reviewed paths already existed as untracked preparation before Ticket 02: the checker, checker tests, platform verification documentation and parity tasks. The local issue is the fifteenth path and remains ignored; it is not force-added to Git. The versioned preparation comprises the other 14 paths plus this closeout record and its review receipts.
| Identity | SHA-256 |
|---|---|
Fixed review content manifest, closeout/reviewed-content.sha256 |
b22cf4a6fafd308bdd5537844794a2c9007268ad215fb52b452fe0612de3fb3b |
Exact Ticket02 review delta, closeout/review.diff |
59806cc2bfafe2713a1d26ea493dc94562ae41a240c038e1579c4d92a5c10fd2 |
| Checked platform input manifest, windows-platform-acceptance-content.sha256 | aae730c74a8b5f2dd7f4c4596b34459e116578b094c226caeba6c761a1a0a3dd |
Generated completion documents, reviewer receipts and final-state manifests are separate evidence, outside their own reviewed-content identity. Subsequent changes to the issue status, task notes and evidence header are editorial: they record user acceptance, retained open requirements and actual delivery state. closeout/editorial-closeout.diff maps those exact old/new documents; it changes no acceptance checkbox, runtime rule, code, configuration or fixture.
Review receipts retain the original /private/tmp/meeting-ticket02-closeout/ packet paths for provenance. That packet is now retained byte-for-byte at artifacts/tests/ticket02/closeout/ (apart from separately checked generated closeout metadata); this explicit path mapping preserves the fixed current/ content and diff identities.
Unrelated primary-checkout work is excluded. The original Ticket01 file, its historical completion and communication Tasks4.2/4.4 are preserved. Requirements in other parity tickets are not included. The smallest reviewed prerequisite candidate is separately identified in closeout/prerequisite-delivery-preview.md; it is not silently included by this closeout.
Requirements and verification
Sources: accepted local Ticket02, the active platform-parity-verification specification, and the explicit user acceptance/closure/commit/cleanup request of 2026-10-06. Requirements and standards verification is retained in closeout/requirements.md; actual test records and the complete host/backend matrix are in windows-platform-acceptance-evidence.md.
| Coverage | Observed result and limits |
|---|---|
| Crop preparation W-C01–05 | Three real-registration cases verify every expected pixel at zero/nonzero origins and ten invalid-bound rejections without output. Normal Windows-TFM test/application cross-build succeeds on macOS, without resource suppression. Native assertions have not executed on Windows. |
| Checker contract W-R01–03 / native names | 52 focused synthetic verifier tests pass, including missing/skipped/failed crop evidence and portable contamination. The two independent named pass groups preserve exactly-once/Passed checks. Synthetic artifact tests do not supply native results. |
| Current portable suite | 655 discovered/results, 653 passed, 2 reasoned Windows skips, 0 failed, net10.0, macOS arm64, .NET10.0.7/SDK10.0.203. The actual discovery/TRX checker succeeds. Windows per-user environment and bitmap/glyph assertions remain unexecuted on this host. |
| WAV prerequisites W-B02/03 | Native say/afconvert generation and PCM/reference/hash validation completed. Generator valid invocation exits0; missing arguments exit2; overwrite attempt exits1 and existing hashes remain unchanged. Known source-clip timing includes synthesis silence; it is not forced word timing or a human diarization result. No ASR/finalizer request was submitted. |
| Host/backend/CI reporting | Actual available service context is macOS, not Windows. Current-content external CI was not observed (unauthenticated access401). Runtime, Outlook, both Windows-only assertions, native crop, Windows profile/backend inventory and real ASR/finalizer results remain open with causes per matrix row. |
| Existing lower-level/native Mac checks | Retained in the successful portable suite and dated Ticket01 records; no transferred Mac answer, stub or compiled method name counts as native Windows evidence. |
All platform inputs and fixture/generator inputs were compared with the archived test/build manifests on 2026-10-06 and matched. The structural closeout changed no substantive input. The existing full suite, normal cross-build and native fixture-generation results are therefore reused. The historical 602/639-pass runs retain their original dates and are not current totals. Feed/NAudio build warnings remain documented in the implementation evidence.
OpenSpec Tasks1.1,1.2 and3.2 stay unchecked. Every original unchecked Ticket02 criterion and matrix row remains unchecked/open. Local ticket closure reflects the user's accepted preparation scope, not completion of the original operational matrix.
Sequential structural review
Substantive review applies to the prepared code and behavior-bearing procedure/evidence documents. Repository AGENTS and the shared code-review criteria cover surrounding context as well as the exact delta. Standards ownership: repeated acceptance knowledge → DRY; public contracts, composition, dependencies and errors → SOLID; readability, simplest current design, helper documentation and remaining manual standards → KISS. Compilation, behavior tests, artifact/fixture correspondence, whitespace and strict OpenSpec validation provide automated coverage.
| Pass | Independent reviewer / receipt | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| DRY | /root/ticket02_dry_review, dry.md |
No binding violation or current defect. DRY-01, a small shared named-pass helper, is consciously deferred: both explicit groups have independent fail-closed coverage and the extraction supplies none of the missing operational acceptance. Same reviewer confirmed no material unresolved current risk and unchanged content. |
| SOLID | /root/ticket02_solid_review, solid.md |
No binding violation or actionable finding; native registration, fixture responsibilities/dependencies and artifact/evidence contracts checked. |
| KISS | /root/ticket02_kiss_review, kiss.md |
No binding violation, actionable simplification or newly discovered behavior defect; public native boundary, helper/documentation coherence and remaining manual standards checked. |
The three receipts cover the fixed manifest/diff above. Editorial acceptance/delivery notes are checked by exact diff, JSON/checkbox consistency, links, whitespace and strict OpenSpec validation; structural review is not required for those status-only changes. No reviewer supplies Windows runtime or external CI evidence.
Delivery and cleanup
Authorized: close local Ticket02, create the local implementation commit on codex/macos-support, and remove unnecessary task-owned worktrees/files. Push, remote issue messaging, whole-change archival and live service restart are outside this request.
Delivery pending prerequisite scope decision. Current HEAD lacks the test checker linkage, Windows test target and isolated hosts that Ticket02 uses. The existing composition guard also directly depends on the uncommitted communication implementation. A Ticket02-only allowlist commit on HEAD would not compile its portable checker tests and would compile its native crop tests out. The prepared 52-file Ticket01/communication prerequisite has separately pinned code, reviews and seven evidence documents, with a concrete two-local-commit preview in closeout/prerequisite-delivery-preview.md. Ticket01's existing closure explicitly held inclusion of that communication prerequisite in both commit and push pending an independent scope answer. This acceptance has not supplied that separate answer. No broken partial commit or implicit prerequisite inclusion is performed.
Before cleanup, all original raw evidence was confirmed identical to the retained artifacts/tests/ticket02/ copy. The four exact pre-Ticket02 baselines, allowlists, fixed review snapshot/diff, verification matrix, reviewer receipts and prerequisite preview are preserved in closeout/. The task-owned /private/tmp/meeting-ticket02-20261003 source/build/native/.NET caches and regeneration files are removable; actual removal and retained evidence correspondence are recorded in closeout/cleanup.md.
The registered /private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-closeout worktree remains necessary for the unresolved delivery step and is retained. The primary checkout, unrelated dirty files, shared caches and live application state are retained. Final delivery can continue from the preserved exact packet once the prerequisite inclusion question is answered, without repeating unchanged implementation checks.