meeting-assistant/openspec/changes/complete-macos-feature-parity/review-receipts/solid.md

SOLID review receipt — Ticket 01

Reviewer: independent /root/review_solid; read-only review on 2026-10-03. No candidate edits, application starts, live-service actions or repeated test runs.

Repository: /private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-closeout. Fixed base: 1b19b08f2e62398661dc24692ce4b776e90e715f (fork/codex/macos-support, resolved from refs and confirmed by coordinator).

Candidate identity:

• Diff: /private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-review-final.diff, SHA-256 40c69e017e5047b0d59348d22ec879122a9f6d02f4f232843847e8fdefe98dac.
• Scoped current-content manifest: /private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-reviewed-content.sha256, SHA-256 b411b6ddffc6ca4e7c2a76c37ff48a49253073e0382abd0ccb213bc531be2a82 (51 code, spec, config and documentation files). All 51 current file checksums match. Generated evidence/hash records are outside this identity.
• Scope: existing macOS communication prerequisite plus Ticket 01 test-target, isolation, verifier and CI changes; future parity-owner implementations excluded.

Result: clean; no actionable binding-rule violation or material SOLID heuristic finding.

Coverage: inspected the diff and surrounding production/test code against repository AGENTS.md, README, relevant OpenSpec requirements/design/tasks, and the current Windows assurance evidence. Checked coherent request-lifecycle ownership, existing prompt interface substitution, validation and failure contracts, original callback lifetimes, shutdown/duplicate/expired response behavior, native transport versus managed business ownership, independent session lifetime and prompt startup, lazy dependency resolution, matching application/test TFMs, Windows/native helper isolation, fixture-only hosted-service suppression with explicit re-enablement, and CI/verifier fail-closed evidence contracts. C#/.NET preference is satisfied by the standalone verifier; Swift is confined to the existing Apple-framework helper boundary. Source/CI ownership stays in this repository; no deployment or active-meeting action is introduced by closeout.

Requirements evidence reviewed and reused: 641 portable results (639 passed, 2 reasoned Windows skips); 22 Linux focused cases (15 passed, 7 reasoned skips); 21 HTTP checks; 38 synthetic verifier fixture cases; seven actual native helper groups. Current normal Windows application and test builds pass with zero errors and no resource suppression after the existing core tray-package correction. Coordinator confirmed the refreshed portable suite used the unchanged candidate inputs.

Unverified boundaries remain explicit: real Windows-TFM discovery/assertion execution, CI runner execution/artifact publication, native notification/menu UI acceptance and later parity-ticket operations. An exit-zero discovery with testhost error and no cases is rejected, not counted as evidence. OpenSpec Task 1.1 and original communication Tasks 4.2/4.4 remain unchecked. This receipt grants no commit, push, merge, archive or ticket-close authority.

Bounded refresh after KISS-01

Current identity: /private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-reviewed-content-v2.sha256, SHA-256 147f83cfe076e27aa5ff29eedc8e9084e2b2e9ee39f9c7ab8a5d834100a0928d (52 files); /private/tmp/meeting-ticket01-review-final-v2.diff, SHA-256 6a9e70bb5dcf0e20f19dd029bdd251f14e528d03037a0a35140254b03066a28b. Both identity hashes and all 52 current file checksums matched. Original 51-file coverage above remains valid without reopening unchanged implementation.

Only additional binding delta reviewed: five lines in openspec/changes/add-macos-desktop-controls/specs/meeting-session/spec.md correct the existing owner's automatic-approval scenario. Unanswered pending workflow/project requests expire or cancel without mutating an agent conversation; notification hiding/dismissal cannot approve them. Spec SHA-256: 7dde9acdcbf2b0917e91e82d1078cb1405d715379eb98f68ea5eff09c48697de.

Result: clean; no new SOLID finding. The corrected owner scenario is coherent with the managed request lifetime, explicit-Yes adapter contract, workflow owner's guarded window creation, public project-association refusal path, and native delegate's ignored dismiss/default actions. It places the fallback rule with its existing desktop owner and introduces no dependency, responsibility or substitution conflict. Unrelated future parity requirements remain excluded.

Reused actual requirements evidence from artifacts/tests/ticket01/closeout/receipt.md and its contract-delta-proof.txt: current TRX Passed records for deadline/origin cancellation, both approval expiry/cancellation cases, workflow denied/expired/shutdown, and all four unapproved/stale project-association cases; corrected owner strict validation passed. No test repetition or source edits were performed. Prior Windows runtime/CI and real native UI acceptance limitations are unchanged.